Skip to content

Toufiq SEO

SEO Strategy

How to Choose an SEO Company: 12 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

The questions I would ask any SEO provider, including me, before signing a contract, and the answers that should make you walk away.

  • Published
  • 5 min read
Business handshake across an office desk, representing choosing an SEO company
On this page
  1. Questions about how they work
  2. Questions about results and reporting
  3. Questions about tactics
  4. Questions about the contract
  5. Red flags in the answers
  6. How to compare two quotes
  7. Agency, freelancer or consultant?
  8. Frequently asked questions

Quick answer: To choose an SEO company, ask how they will diagnose your site before they quote, what exactly they will do each month, how they report results, who does the work, and what happens if you leave. A good provider explains their reasoning in plain language, ties the work to leads or sales, never guarantees rankings and lets you own every account and asset they create.

Hiring the wrong SEO provider is expensive twice. You pay for months of work that does not move anything, and then you pay again for someone to undo shortcuts like spammy links or thin pages. Google itself has a page on how to hire an SEO, and it makes the same point I make to every business owner: a useful provider asks a lot of questions about your business before promising anything.

These are the questions I would ask any SEO company, including me.

Questions about how they work

1. What will you look at before you send a price?

A provider who quotes a monthly fee without looking at your site, your Google Business Profile and your competitors is selling a package, not a plan. Expect at least a short review of where you stand now. A full SEO audit is the deeper version of this step.

2. What exactly will you do in the first 90 days?

“Ongoing optimization” is not an answer. You want a list: fix these technical problems, rewrite these service pages, complete the Business Profile, set up review requests, publish this content. If they cannot tell you what month one looks like, they probably do not know.

3. How do you decide what to work on first?

Good SEO is prioritization. Listen for reasoning like “your service pages are not indexed, so content work would be wasted until that is fixed.” Be wary of a provider who does the same steps in the same order for every client.

4. Who actually does the work?

Many agencies sell with a senior strategist and deliver with junior staff or outsourced teams. That is not always bad, but you should know. Ask who writes the content, who builds links and who you talk to every month.

Questions about results and reporting

5. How will you measure success?

The right answer involves calls, form submissions, bookings or sales from organic search, not just rankings and traffic. My guide to SEO KPIs explains what a useful report contains.

6. How long before I should expect to see movement?

An honest answer is a range with reasons. Technical fixes and Business Profile work can show results within weeks; competitive rankings usually take months. See how long SEO takes for realistic timelines.

7. Do you guarantee rankings?

The only acceptable answer is no. Google’s own hiring guidance says no one can guarantee a number one ranking. A guarantee usually means the provider will chase an easy, low-value keyword or use tactics that put your site at risk.

Questions about tactics

8. How do you build links?

Ask for examples of the kinds of sites they get links from. Buying links that pass ranking value is against Google’s spam policies. Local sponsorships, partner pages, digital PR and genuinely useful content are the safer routes. I cover these in link building for small businesses.

9. Do you use AI to write content?

AI-assisted writing is not banned by Google, but mass-producing pages with little original value is. Ask how content is researched, who edits it and how they add experience and accuracy that a generic tool cannot.

10. Have you worked with businesses like mine?

Industry experience helps, especially in regulated fields like healthcare, law or finance. If they claim results, ask for a case study you can verify, or a reference you can call.

Questions about the contract

11. Who owns the accounts and the work?

You should own your website, domain, Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and every piece of content. Providers should be added as users, not owners. If they built your site on their platform, ask what happens to it if you leave.

12. What is the notice period, and what happens when we stop?

Long lock-in contracts protect the provider, not you. Month-to-month or a short initial term with a clear notice period is reasonable. Ask whether links or listings they created will be removed if you cancel.

Red flags in the answers

What they sayWhat it usually means
“We guarantee page one”Easy keywords, risky tactics, or both
“Our methods are proprietary”They do not want you to see what they do
“We will build 100 links a month”Low-quality or paid links
“You need to be on our platform”You may lose your site if you leave
“Rankings are the only report you need”No connection to leads or revenue

How to compare two quotes

Price differences are often scope differences. Line the proposals up and check:

  • Hours or deliverables per month, in writing.
  • Who does the work and how senior they are.
  • Whether content, links and technical fixes are included or billed separately.
  • Reporting format and how often you meet.
  • Contract length and exit terms.

A cheaper quote that covers half the work is not cheaper. A more expensive quote full of vague “optimization” is not better.

Agency, freelancer or consultant?

Agencies bring more people and capacity. Freelancers are usually the most affordable but are stretched across many clients. A consultant sits in between: one senior person doing the strategy and much of the work, with a direct line to you. I am a consultant, so I am biased, but the right model depends on how much work you need and how much you want to be involved. If you are leaning toward an agency for a reseller arrangement, my white label SEO checklist covers that case.

If you want to see how I answer these questions, read what an SEO consultant does or look. You can also book a consultation and ask me all twelve.

Frequently asked questions

How much should I pay an SEO company?

It depends on competition, scope and who does the work. Compare deliverables rather than headline prices, and be cautious of very cheap monthly packages that promise everything.

Should I sign a 12-month SEO contract?

Only if the provider has earned that trust or the price reflects the commitment. A short first term lets you judge the work before committing longer.

Can I check an SEO company’s past results?

Ask for case studies with context, and for permission to speak to a past client. Screenshots of traffic graphs without names or dates are easy to fake.

Is it a bad sign if an SEO company contacts me first?

Not always, but unsolicited emails promising rankings are usually mass outreach. Google’s hiring guidance specifically warns about them.

Sources: Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?; Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search.

Toufiq-ur Rahman Kobir
Written by

Independent SEO consultant

Google, Maps and AI search

Toufiq-ur Rahman Kobir is an independent SEO consultant who helps US businesses get found on Google Search, Google Maps and in AI answers. He has led SEO as SEO Manager at a US agency, managing more than twenty webmasters, content managers and copywriters, and now works directly with a small number of clients on technical SEO, local SEO, content strategy and AI search visibility.

Works with
US businesses, remotely
Background
SEO Manager at a US agency
Focus
Technical SEO, content strategy, AI search
Status
Taking on a limited number of clients
Scroll to Top