Quick answer: The biggest SEO red flags are guaranteed rankings, secret or proprietary methods, packages of hundreds of links for a small fee, claims of a special relationship with Google, contracts that give the provider ownership of your accounts or website, and reports that only show rankings for terms nobody searches. Legitimate SEO is explainable, measurable and leaves you owning everything.
A large share of the audits I do start with cleaning up after another provider. The patterns repeat so often that I can usually guess what happened from the first email. None of this means every agency is dishonest. It means the industry has low barriers to entry, and business owners rarely have a way to check the work.
Red flag 1: Guaranteed rankings
Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO states plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. Providers who guarantee page one either pick obscure keywords that are easy to rank for, or use tactics that may work briefly and then get the site penalized.
Red flag 2: “Our methods are secret”
Good SEO is not a secret. The fundamentals are documented by Google itself. A provider should be able to tell you exactly what they changed on your site and why. If they will not, you cannot judge whether it was worth paying for, or whether it was risky.
Red flag 3: Cheap link packages
“500 backlinks for $99” means links from spammy directories, private blog networks, hacked sites or comment spam. Buying links that pass ranking credit violates Google’s spam policies. Google mostly ignores these links now, so the best case is wasted money. The worst case is a manual action. My guide to link building for small businesses shows what real link building looks like.
Red flag 4: A “special relationship” with Google
There is no such thing as a Google SEO partner. Google Partners is a program for Google Ads, not organic search. Anyone who claims they can get you priority in Google’s organic results, or who says they are calling “from Google” about your listing, is misleading you. Google’s Business Profile team warns about scam calls that use its name.
Red flag 5: They own your stuff
- The provider registered your domain in their own name.
- Your Google Business Profile is owned by their account, with you as a manager or not listed at all.
- Your website is built on their proprietary platform and cannot be exported.
- Analytics and Search Console are in their accounts.
If you leave, you may lose all of it. Always own your accounts and give providers user access. I explain this in my list of questions to ask before hiring an SEO company.
Red flag 6: Reports full of vanity metrics
A report showing you rank first for “best licensed emergency plumbing company in north Springfield” is meaningless if no one searches for it. Reports should show calls, leads, sales and non-branded organic traffic. If they never mention business outcomes, ask why. My guide to SEO KPIs explains what good reporting looks like.
Red flag 7: Fake reviews and keyword-stuffed profiles
Some providers buy reviews or add city names and keywords to your business name on Google. Both break Google’s rules. Fake reviews also break the FTC’s rule on consumer reviews, which allows civil penalties. Keyword stuffing in the business name is one of the most common reasons profiles get suspended.
Red flag 8: Mass-produced pages
Hundreds of near-identical city pages or AI-written blog posts published in a week can look like progress. Google’s spam policies call this scaled content abuse when the main purpose is manipulating rankings rather than helping people. It often ends in pages that never get indexed, or worse.
Red flag 9: Long lock-in contracts with no exit
A 12 or 24-month contract with heavy cancellation fees protects the provider. A short initial term with a clear notice period gives you leverage if the work is not delivered.
How to check what a past provider did
- Check Search Console for manual actions and the Links report for unusual link sources.
- Check who owns your Business Profile, domain and analytics accounts.
- Search for your business name and look for strange directory listings or duplicate profiles.
- Read your own site for pages you did not know existed.
- Ask for a list of work completed each month, in writing.
If you suspect damage, my SEO audit covers links, content, technical issues and account ownership. I tell you what to keep, what to fix and what to leave alone.
Frequently asked questions
Is cheap SEO always a scam?
No, but very cheap packages that promise everything usually cut corners. Ask exactly what is delivered for the price.
Can bad SEO get my site penalized?
Yes. Link schemes, fake reviews, cloaking and scaled spam content can all lead to manual actions or algorithmic demotion.
How do I get my Google Business Profile back from an old agency?
Ask them to transfer primary ownership. If they refuse, Google has an ownership request process in Business Profile Help.
What does honest SEO look like?
Clear priorities, written monthly work, reporting tied to leads and no guarantees about Google’s decisions.
Sources: Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?; Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search; Federal Register: FTC Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials.




